11 Sandwich Cake Recipes That Will Be the Talk of ALL Your Parties (2024)

From announcing her tenth album Midnights during an acceptance speech to breaking ticket-selling records to gearing up for her feature film directorial debut, Taylor Swift continues to surprise us. And that includes her Eras Tour, which kicked off in Glendale, Arizona on March 17.

At one of her Texas shows, she surprised the audience by swapping a song on the setlist for something she had never performed live. "You think you can just go online, you think you can just scroll and know the setlist, you think you can just come prepared," she said onstage. "Let it be said about the Eras Tour: we're tricksy."

In addition to her self-proclaimed "setlist hi-jinx," every night of the tour will see two surprise songs. That is, until Taylor started doing mash-ups, which means the surprise song segment can have as many songs as she wants! She did something totally new in Sydney, Australia and played mash-ups every single night.

All in all, even if your favorite song didn't make the original setlist, you might still get to hear it (even if you're streaming the concert on TikTok). While we wait for The Tortured Poets Department — and maybe Reputation (Taylor's Version) — here's everything she's played on the tour.

Taylor Swift Eras Tour Surprise Songs For 2024

11 Sandwich Cake Recipes That Will Be the Talk of ALL Your Parties (1)

Image via Chloe Williams/Brit + Co

Taylor Swift Eras Tour Surprise Songs For 2023

11 Sandwich Cake Recipes That Will Be the Talk of ALL Your Parties (2)

Image via Kristina Kung

Taylor Swift Eras Tour ticket with rainbow star confetti.

Glendale, AZ on March 17: "mirrorball" and "Tim McGraw"
Glendale, AZ on March 18: "State of Grace" and "this is me trying"
Las Vegas, NV on March 24: "Our Song" and "Snow on the Beach"
Las Vegas, NV on March 25: "cowboy like me" with Marcus Mumford and "White Horse"
Arlington, TX on March 31: "Sad Beautiful Tragic" and "Ours"
Arlington, TX on April 1: "Death By A Thousand Cuts" and "Clean"
Arlington, TX on April 2: "Jump Then Fall" and "The Lucky One"
Tampa, FL on April 13: "Speak Now" and "Treacherous"
Tampa, FL on April 14: "The Great War" with Aaron Dessner and "You're On Your Own, Kid"
Tampa, FL on April 15: "mad woman" with Aaron Dessner and "Mean"
Houston, TX on April 21: "Wonderland" and "You're Not Sorry"
Houston, TX on April 22: "A Place In This World" and "Today Was A Fairytale"
Houston, TX on April 23: "Begin Again" and "Cold As You"
Atlanta, GA on April 28: "The Other Side Of The Door" and "Coney Island"
Atlanta, GA on April 29: "High Infidelity" and "Gorgeous"
Atlanta, GA on April 30: "I Bet You Think About Me" and "How You Get The Girl"
Nashville, TN on May 5: "Sparks Fly" and "Teardrops On My Guitar"
Nashville, TN on May 6: "Out of the Woods" and "Fifteen"
Nashville, TN on May 7: "Would've Could've Should've" with Aaron Dessner and "Mine"
Philadelphia, PA on May 12: "gold rush" and 'Come Back... Be Here'
Philadelphia, PA on May 13: "Forever & Always" and "This Love"
Philadelphia, PA on May 14: "Hey Stephen" and "The Best Day"

11 Sandwich Cake Recipes That Will Be the Talk of ALL Your Parties (3)

Image via Chloe Williams/Brit + Co

Foxborough, MA on May 19: "Should've Said No" and "Better Man"
Foxborough, MA on May 20: "Question...?" and "Invisible"
Foxborough, MA on May 21: "I Think He Knows" and "Red"
East Rutherford, NJ on May 26: "Getaway Car" with Jack Antanoff and "Maroon"
East Rutherford, NJ on May 27: "Holy Ground" and "False God"
East Rutherford, NJ on May 28: "Clean" and "Welcome to New York"
Chicago, IL on June 2: "I Wish You Would" and "the lakes"
Chicago, IL on June 3: "You All Over Me" with Maren Morris and "I Don't Wanna Live Forever"
Chicago, IL on June 4: "Hits Different" and "The Moment I Knew"
Detroit, MI on June 9: “Haunted” and “I Almost Do”
Detroit, MI on June 10: “All You Had to Do Was Stay” and “Breathe”
Pittsburgh, PA on June 16: “Mr. Perfectly Fine” and “The Last Time”
Pittsburgh, PA on June 17: “Seven” with Aaron Dessner and “The Story of Us”
Minneapolis, MN on June 23: “Paper Rings” and “If This Was a Movie”
Minneapolis, MN on June 24: “Dear John” and “Daylight”
Cincinnati, OH on June 30: “I’m Only Me When I’m With You” and “Evermore”
Cincinnati, OH on July 1: “Ivy” with Aaron Dessner, “I Miss You, I’m Sorry” with Gracie Abrams, and “Call It What You Want”
Kansas City, MO on July 7: “Never Grow Up” and “When Emma Falls in Love”
Kansas City, MO on July 8: “Last Kiss” and “Dorothea”
Denver, CO on July 14: “Picture to Burn” and “Timeless”
Denver, CO on July 15: “Starlight” and “Back to December”

11 Sandwich Cake Recipes That Will Be the Talk of ALL Your Parties (4)

Image via Haley Sprankle/Brit + Co

Seattle, WA on July 22: “This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things” and “Everything Has Changed”
Seattle, WA on July 23: “Message in a Bottle” and “Tied Together With a Smile”
Santa Clara, CA on July 28: “Right Where You Left Me” and “Castles Crumbling”
Santa Clara, CA on July 29: “Stay Stay Stay” and “All of the Girls You Loved Before”
Los Angeles, CA on Aug. 3: "I Can See You" and "Maroon"
Los Angeles, CA on Aug. 4: "Our Song" and "You Are In Love"
Los Angeles, CA on Aug. 5: "Death by a Thousand Cuts" and "You're On Your Own, Kid"
Los Angeles, CA on Aug. 7: "Dress" and "Exile"
Los Angeles, CA on Aug. 8: "I Know Places" and "King Of My Heart"
Los Angeles, CA on Aug. 9: "New Romantics" and "New Year's Day"
Mexico City, Mexico on Aug. 24: "I Forgot That You Existed" and "Sweet Nothing"
Mexico City, Mexico on Aug. 25: "Tell Me Why" and "Snow On The Beach"
Mexico City, Mexico on Aug. 26: "Cornelia Street" and "You're On Your Own, Kid"
Mexico City, Mexico on Aug. 27: "Afterglow" and "Maroon"
Buenos Aires, Argentina on Nov. 9: "The Very First Night" and "Labyrinth"
Buenos Aires, Argentina on Nov. 11: "Is It Over Now?" & "Out Of The Woods" mash-up and "End Game"
Buenos Aires, Argentina on Nov. 12: "Better Than Revenge" and “slu*t!”
Rio De Janeiro, Brazil on Nov. 17: "Stay Beautiful" and "Suburban Legends"
Rio De Janeiro, Brazil on Nov. 19: "Dancing With Our Hands Tied" and "Bigger Than The Whole Sky"
Rio De Janeiro, Brazil on Nov. 20: "Me!" and "So It Goes..."

Does anyone sing Taylor Swift's Eras Tour surprise songs with her?

11 Sandwich Cake Recipes That Will Be the Talk of ALL Your Parties (5)

Image via Mike Coppola/Getty Images for iHeartRadio

Taylor Swift will occasionally bring out her opener to sing the surprise songs with her, like she did with Sabrina Carpenter in Sydney, Australia! After crazy weather preventer Sabrina from performing her set at the beginning of the concert, Taylor brought her out for a medley of "White Horse" from Fearless (Taylor's Version) and "Coney Island" from Evermore.

How does Taylor Swift choose surprise songs?

11 Sandwich Cake Recipes That Will Be the Talk of ALL Your Parties (6)

Image via Chloe Williams/Brit + Co

It seems that Taylor Swift's surprise song choices are somewhat last minute and based on what she wants to play, but we're thinking that two of her songs from Houston are more than meets the eye — er, more than meets the ear?

Twitter users recently brought up Speak Now (Taylor's Version) when images of Taylor filming in Liverpool went viral. The other two people in the photos appear to be Joey King and Taylor Lautner, who both played a role in the original Speak Now: Joey King was featured in the "Mean" music video and Taylor Lautner is the subject of

And we're talking about Speak Now (Taylor's Version) again after the April 22 concert because of her surprise songs. After all, "A Place In This World" (which is featured in Joey King's Ramona and Beezus) and "Today Was A Fairytale" (which is a part of Taylor Swift and Taylor Lautner's Valentine's Day) feels very intentional. Turns out, we were right because she brought Joey and Taylor onstage during the Speak Now (Taylor's Version) launch party to premiere the music video!

In addition to playing requests from her openers during the surprise song segment, Taylor seems to choose songs based on her celebrity attendees. The Summer I Turned Pretty's Jenny Han and Lola Tung attended the May 27 show, where Taylor played "False God," which was featured in season one.

And during her last performance in LA, Taylor Swift chose "New Romantics" from 1989 and "New Year's Day" from reputation. This is very telling because for one, "New Romantics" was the only song from 1989 that she hadn't sung yet, and it came right after the 1989 (Taylor's Version) announcement! And based on this frame from the "Karma" music video, we might be getting reputation TV after 1989 TV. So "New Year's Day" was the perfect follow-up!

November 19 and 20, at the end of Taylor Swift's time in Rio de Janeiro, she played two songs from Reputation: "Dancing With Our Hands Tied" and "So It Goes..." (both of which are two of my all-time favorite Taylor songs and are very under-appreciated). This leaves "I Did Something Bad" as the final Reputation surprise song, and Swifties are convinced we'll get the announcement before the end of November. Fans also pointed out both "Me!" and "So It Goes..." feature a 1,2,3 countdown in the lyrics — and there are only three shows left before Taylor takes another break. It's the perfect time for an announcement if you ask me!

What surprise song would you like to hear during Taylor Swift's Eras Tour? Let us know in the comments and follow us on Facebook for the latest pop culture updates.

Lead image via Haley Sprankle/B+C

This post has been updated.